Dry-Aged Beef at Eataly: Interview with Peter Molinari

Peter Molinari

If your idea of a summer weekend feast involves Flintstone’s size steaks on a hot grill, then July 18th is your lucky day. Eataly is celebrating Dry-Aged Steak with a sale on its Prime Dry-Aged Ribeye from Kansas’ Diamond Creek Ranch.

Here’s a definition of dry-aging from Eataly’s website:

Dry-aging is the process of allowing large cuts of meat to rest in a controlled, open-air environment for an extended period of time. This allows for enzymes in the meat to break down the proteins and concentrate the flavors, resulting in tender meat with a complexity of flavor that is unique to dry aged beef

Super Chef turned to Eataly’s head butcher, Peter Molinari to find out more about dry-aged beef.

Ribs by Peter Molinari

Super Chef: Is dry aging your preferred method of aging a good steak. why?

Peter Molinari: I have always preferred dry age beef. It really is the most flavorful and tender steak.

Super Chef: For a charcoal grill, what is the best cut to feed a large crowd (i.e. spending a bit less per pound)?

Peter Molinari: The best steak for a large group will be prime dry age sirloin. It’s $15.80/pound at Eataly. It really has great flavor.

Super Chef: What about feeding only a few people (spending a bit more)?

Peter Molinari: If you want to spend more for a couple of people, I would pick the prime dry age Riley. This is a high-quality steak with great fat content. It will always be juicy and tender.

Super Chef: Would you get a different cut for a gas grill?

Peter Molinari: Not necessarily – you can cook steaks on different flames. Your cooking style will be different.

Super Chef: If you just want steak without a lot of sauces and other flavors, what would you recommend putting on a steak before cooking or after? S &P? Soy Sauce? Nothing? Something else?

Peter Molinari: I recommend with a good steak to be as simple as possible. You should only need salt, pepper, and olive oil. A good steak should have all the flavor you need.

Super Chef: How long will one of your steaks keep in the fridge? What about the freezer?

Peter Molinari: You are looking for about 3 days max. You always want to make sure you change the paper the steak is wrapped in. I never recommend freezing your steak. You will loose a lot of flavor and moisture. All of the blood and water that come out of the steak during the defrost will impact the integrity of the steak.

Super Chef: How many ounces per person should you buy?

Peter Molinari: I typically recommend 8-10 ounces per person.

Super Chef: Do you recommend a thermometer for testing doneness or slicing into the meat or testing against the muscle between finger and thumb?

Peter Molinari: I recommend using a thermometer. Most people aren’t experienced enough for thumb muscle test. I would never cut a steak until after it rested.

Super Chef: There is quite a bit of fat on these steaks – is it OK to trim that off, or should you serve with fat and let everyone cut it away (or eat it)?

Peter Molinari: Some steaks have a good amount of fat. Fat is flavor and moisture for the steak. If you cut it off before cooking your steak will lose flavor.

Super Chef: Any other tips?

Peter Molinari: You always want to get the grill as hot as possible. You want to use tongs, not a fork. Always only flip the steak once. Make sure you let the steak rest for at least 10 minutes before cutting it.

Of course, you don’t have to wait for a sale, a weekend, or a special day. You just have to get that grill hot, and choose a good steak, and a have an appetite.

Eataly logo

About Juliette Rossant

Juliette Rossant is an American author, journalist, and poet. Following publication of her book Super Chef (2004), she began an online magazine... (more)